Posted On March 29, 2017 by Print This Post

Writing the Inspirational Historical: How Much is Too Much – Ruth Kaufman

Today’s post is a rerun of one that originally appeared at RU on December 17, 2014. Scroll down to see Ruth’s more recent releases.

Help me welcome Ruth Kaufman who has done a very unique thing with her soon-to-be-published book. Read on and find out what she’s done!

RuthKaufman63The research required to write a believable historical in any period can be daunting. But writing them gave me a reason to acquire many beautiful and fascinating books. However, because I’ve invested in more than 200 on 15th century England and learned quite a bit about that time, I’m not inspired to move to a different century or country…despite the ongoing popularity of Regency and Scottish settings.

And the farther back you go, the fewer original materials exist. Scholars and historians are less certain or uncertain about what actually happened, say, at a certain battle. On one hand, I might need to know where King Henry VI was or what he was doing on a certain day and be frustrated when I can’t find out after checking several sources. On the other, when more than one resource says something like, “No one knows about X or Y,” I take that as a gift, an opportunity to fill in the blanks and create the information I need.

But how much history is too much? You want to include enough setting and detail so readers feel part of the environment, while not overdoing details and making it sound like Ruth the author wants to pour out every fact discovered during meticulous research. When an editor sent me a second revision letter for the Golden Heart® winning manuscript, AT HIS COMMAND, which I’m self-publishing next month, she wrote, “your commitment to historical accuracy is one of our favorite things about the manuscript…but at times the accurate depiction of court interferes with the romance.” The difficulty in making the requested changes was trying to guess which times she thought details interfered and which she liked. Of course, another editor or reader might have a different opinion, which could send an author spinning down a rabbit hole…

RuthKaufman_AtHisCommand_His_285kbBecause religion was a huge part of medieval life, I also wanted to write an inspirational. The faith element must also be believable. As a pantser, an author who doesn’t plot in advance, I needed a reason for my hero to want to leave court. Since he was weary after fighting in the Hundred Years’ War, wanting to go on a pilgrimage (popular at the time) made the perfect starting point for his faith journey. The heroine had lost her family to plague, and lost her faith because of it.

Incorporating a faith element, IMO, is similar to incorporating history. Not only does it require research and decisions on what to include when, the author must ask, “How much is too much?” You want to appeal to inspirational readers without preaching. Your hero and heroine should each have a faith journey that resolves in the end like the romance and conflict. But, as with history, those journeys shouldn’t overwhelm the romance.

I prefer historicals in which real history affects the characters and plot over romances simply set in a castle. Characters wear the right clothes and eat the right foods, but the plot could be moved to a different century with ease. So I weave actual historical figures and events into the story.

If writing historicals or inspirational historicals interests you, here a few suggestions to help you get started:

Choose your time period by assessing your interests. What events, notable people or places resonate with you? Are you drawn to art or fashion from a certain time? I chose mid-fifteenth century England because I was in a production of Richard III in college and wondered how much liberty Shakespeare had taken. The more I read about the actual RIII, the more I wanted to know. At the time, there were already romances involving him, so I chose a less familiar king.

RuthKaufman_AtHisCommand_Ins_300kbWho decides what to include? Which historical tidbits to include are often chosen by the author to create interesting plots, settings and characters. In one ms, I used a real historical mystery that still hasn’t been solved as the catalyst for the plot. But the faith element, IMO, needs to come from each character’s story arc. Thus, what to include is chosen by the character, if the author is seeing through their eyes. Let him or her guide you, perhaps via interviews about their back story. You might pursue your faith element as you do GMC (goals, motivation and conflict) in any romance, asking, “What does each character want or not want in terms of religion and why, and what’s keeping them from getting it?” That being said, there were a couple of places where I did go back and add something if I felt the inspirational element hadn’t been mentioned in too many pages or the progression of the journey wasn’t clear enough.

Decide when to research and when to write. You may spend hours and hours immersed in research, but only new words on the page count. After I had a general understanding of events and notes on key details, I researched as I wrote. I’d leave this: // wherever I needed to fill in what they wore or ate, for example. That way I wouldn’t be pulled out of the writing zone, and could search later for // to fill in the blanks. On occasion, adding a new detail, such as, say, a sauced chicken dish, could heighten the scene I already had. Examples: if the sauce was too spicy and made her choke, the hero would then rush to her side. The dish reminded her of her deceased mother. I try to sprinkle details rather than have a whole paragraph(s) of description.

Assess the amount of each element: You could go through your draft and color code faith, history and romance to make sure the romance stands out. I actually searched my manuscript for the words faith, God and prayer to see how often I’d used them.

In the end, how much is too much in any book is up to the author first, then the readers.


What do you like to see in historicals and/or historical inspirationals as a reader and/or as an author?


Ruth Kaufman is a Chicago on-camera and voiceover talent and freelance writer, editor and speaker with a J.D. and a Master’s in Radio/TV.

Two versions of her medieval AT HIS COMMAND release January 14, 2015. One is inspirational and mild, the other has no faith element and opens the bedroom doors.

Writing accolades include Romance Writers of America® 2011 Golden Heart® winner and runner up in RT Book Reviews’ national American Title II contest. Her true, short story, “The Scrinch” is in St. Martin’s anthology The Spirit of Christmas, foreword by Debbie Macomber.

She’s appeared in indie features, short films, web series and national and local TV commercials, and has voiced hundreds of explainer videos, e-learning courses, commercials and assorted characters.

Learn more at and Follow her on Twitter: @ruthkaufman or Facebook: Ruth Kaufman Author & Actress.

Order links:

AT HIS COMMAND-Inspirational Version

AT HIS COMMAND-Historical Romance Version






Similar Posts:

Share Button

Craft of Writing


13 Responses to “Writing the Inspirational Historical: How Much is Too Much – Ruth Kaufman”

  1. Ruth – If you happen to check in today, I’d love to hear the results of your experiment. Tell us what you’ve been up to since this guest post was first published!

    Posted by Becke Martin Davis | March 29, 2017, 8:35 am
    • Hi Becke,

      Thanks for asking! Unfortunately, my experiment of publishing an “open bedroom door” version with the hero on the cover and a “closed bedroom door” with a faith element version featuring the heroine on the cover failed.

      The hero’s book sold and continues to sell, but not the heroine’s.

      Why? Perhaps:
      –inspirational and/or sweet readers don’t like the idea that there’s another, spicier, version.

      –because I didn’t promote the heroine’s version as much.

      –because the other 3 books and novella I’ve published since are all “open door.”


      Posted by Ruth Kaufman | March 29, 2017, 9:52 am
  2. Thanks for sharing this, Ruth. I was curious because I read both types of books – sometimes based on my mood, sometimes by pure happenstance. I’ve heard there’s a trend toward more “closed door” books, but I haven’t noticed it much in the books I’ve read lately.

    Posted by Becke Martin Davis | March 29, 2017, 10:45 am
  3. Ruth, I missed the original issue of this post, and enjoyed it today. At His Command is on my staggering TBR pile!
    I am a faith-filled woman, but am very picky about the inspirationals I read. I will shut the book if it’s preachy!
    I am most interested in the characters and their journeys, that’s what draws me into the story. I look forward to getting time to read your book, which with a graduating HS senior in the house, won’t happen until later this year, lol!

    Posted by Sherry Weddle | March 29, 2017, 10:59 am
  4. I agree with Sheryl. I avoid inspirationals that are too preachy. Their goal is to evangelize, and frankly, readers of such books are already there. I very much appreciate inspirationals (and have read many) that weave faith into a character’s life in a matter-of-fact way, no matter where he/she is in a faith journey, and show how a life in faith can bring about a different perspective. I am a wanta-be writer working on a “closed-door” inspy book that has a quite a bit of before-and-after pillow talk. My characters view the physical aspect as an enjoyable part of their martial bond. Not sure if this will ever find a publisher, but it’s who they are and I cannot write them otherwise. Thanks, Ruth!

    Posted by Janice Laird | March 29, 2017, 11:43 am
  5. Hope you finish your book soon, Janice! I found that inspy publishers can have their own rules. For example, some wouldn’t even look at AHC despite the Golden Heart win because it was medieval.

    Posted by Ruth Kaufman | March 29, 2017, 1:04 pm
  6. Ruth – Thanks so much for joining us today!

    Posted by Becke Martin Davis | March 29, 2017, 10:38 pm
  7. Ruth, your article was marvelous. My current WiP is a Historical, although is not a romance, at least not as the main plot. Like you, I am fixated on England but on the 19th century [Victorian Era]. It is the social worker in me, I believe.

    Posted by Glynis Jolly | March 30, 2017, 7:54 am


  1. […]… Have you added religion to your historical? It was a big part of history. […]

  2. […] Kaufman discusses Writing the Inspirational Historical: How Much is Too Much? on Romance […]

Post a comment

Upcoming Posts





Follow Us